Bilezikian, widely known as "Dr. Check out our concert lineup to watch one of your favorite artists or discover someone new! Would you consider making a tax-deductible donation to help our journalists continue to report the truth and restore the church? Dummitt said though fewer are going to Willow Creeks seven campuses than two years ago, those who do show up are incredibly generous. Per-capita giving, he said, meets or exceeds giving at other large churches. Today's picture is vastly different. The co-founder of Willow Creek Community Church has filed a lawsuit charging church elders with defaming him in statements they made earlier this year. Willow Creek Community Church is a basic fundagelical megachurch based in a Chicago suburb. That somehow being famous or drawing the most people is equivalent to living our the After Hybels stepped down, the church . After Smith finished speaking, his congregation quietly applauded for an extended period of time. 1. Seems like their is going to be less Senior Pastor oversight. Many members seemed sympathetic. Now some evangelicals are talking about turning Willow Creeks painful episode into a teaching moment for churches in the #MeToo era. No One Knows. 1 Song. Be very bothered. Larson and the elders made it clear not only does the church need a fresh start, but a clear running lane to heal. Jack Graham, of Prestonwood Baptist Church in Plano, Tex., who said he worried that people would view the scandal as evidence that all evangelicals were hypocrites. A statement from elders at the Willow Creek church. Return to homepage. As a result of the controversy over the churchs handling of the allegations, the two pastors who succeeded himCarter and lead pastor Heather Larsonresigned, as did the churchs entire elder board. Some people attending the summit said they believe the decision by the elders and pastor to step down will mean a fresh start for the church. Adds a layer of thoughtfulness to the unease surrounding such a statement! Its unclear who will replace De La Morra at the Chicago campus. Hybels repeatedly denied the allegations. a transition which he has planned meticulously, Kara Powell, executive director of a research center at Fuller Theological Seminary, 21 Funny Church Signs Even Jesus Would Laugh At. Morris made the offer while he was a guest speaker in February, The Roys Report previously reported. LATEST on Huge Willow Creek Fallout: 'Blinded' to Suffering of Women Claiming Sexual Abuse by Hybels This is not the first time Hybels has been the subject of such claims. . Give a gift of $30 or more to The Roys Report this month, and you will receive Escaping the Maze of Spiritual Abuse by Dr. Lisa Oakley and Justin Humphreys. Ortberg, along with Jon Wallace, president of Azusa Pacific University, and Kara Powell, executive director of a research center at Fuller Theological Seminary, resigned from the association board in January 2015, later citing what they deemed an inadequate review, the Tribune states. De Vries said the association is making three commitments moving forward, including pursuing an advisory leadership council to provide oversight for an independent investigation. The Willow Creek Elder Board confirmed Tuesday night in an online postthat it had decided to restrict Bilezikian from serving within the church. Heather Larson has resigned her position as lead pastor with the Willow Creek megachurch in South Barrington, Illinois, north west of Chicago. Larson told Church Executive in an October 2014 interview about what it was like working with Bill Hybels, He brings out the best in me and encourages me to take on new challenges. Chicago-area Willow Creek Community Church, a megachurch, was held up as an example of how to "do" evangelical Christianity. There would be no Willow Creek without Gilbert Bilezikian, Hybels told Christianity Today in 2000. Were all failed people., How the Willow Creek Church Scandal Has Stunned the Evangelical World, https://www.nytimes.com/2018/08/09/us/evangelicals-willow-creek-scandal.html. And Crystal Lake is $173,230 short of its yearly budget of $884,000, according to Willow Creeks website. Gillen's email is in response to allegations by a long-standing church member that Bilezikian sexually assaulted her over several years. Several speakers and many churches backed out of the conference because of the controversy. On April 2, 2018, Ortberg published a post to his blog which articulated his concerns with the way Willow Creek handled the investigation of the allegations. They are asking what kind of structures churches need to keep their pastors accountable, how to handle allegations of sexual harassment, and how to ensure that men working alongside women do not violate boundaries. An update posted today on the churchs website states that staff were told May 4 that some positions would be eliminated. When the Willow Creek Association also decided to drop the investigation against Hybels, more board members decided to walk. Catholic priest renounces faith.. 4. These are the folks that get the job done on the human level. Because of the gospel. Megan is passionate about seeking and proclaiming the truth. The idea that we have colluded to manufacture or encourage these stories is untrue and a diversion. One pastor cannot effectively pastor 20,000 people. New lead pastor Rev. Those allegations led a major investigation by the churchs elders into the handling of the misconduct claims. The centralized mega-church model is an historical aberration for various reasons. Monarchy of Christ, not pastoral monarchy, is the NT model. The leaders Heather Larson, elders, etc. Because it sits in contrast with: Let everyone give joyfully what he feels in his heart, not under compulsion, for God loves a cheerful giver.. The cuts will result in $6.5 million in savings, according to todays statement, and staff costs will make up 52% of the churchs overall budget next year. "My heart breaks for Pat Baranowski and all victims of Bill Hybels at Willow Creek. Photo: Mark Black/AP Photo. Please check your information and try again or call us at 1-800-759-0700. 2023 The Christian Broadcasting Network, Inc., A nonprofit 501 (c)(3) Charitable Organization. William Hybels (born December 12, 1951) is an American church figure and author. Willow Creeks elder board has a released a statement in response to the Chicago Tribune article that was published last night. Bible teacher Jen Wilkin addresses criticism of her views on sending children to public schools, Marvin Winans Perfecting Church sued by Detroit over stalled church project, Christian school forfeits girls' basketball playoff game to protest male player on opposing team, Revival at Kentucky college faces hurdles from school leadership, moves worship off-campus. That was just before COVID, but its also the year investigators found that sexual misconduct allegations against Willow Creek founder Bill Hybels were credible. She has the longsuffering and altruistic nature of foreign friends and missionaries to humbly thank for this experience. He maintains he did none of the things his accusers are saying and states the lies you read about in the Tribune article are the tools this group is using to try to keep me from ending my tenure here at Willow with my reputation intact.. Earlier efforts by the board of elders to investigate were inconclusive, and Mr. Hybels retained their trust until the news reports were published. Am I missing something? She told her full story in a Facebook post dated Jan. 25, including the fact she first notified church leadership in 2010 but was disappointed by their response and lack of action. We believe that Dr. B engaged in inappropriate behavior, and the harm he caused was inexcusable, Willow Creeks acting lead pastor Steve Gillen wrote Monday in an email to church staff obtained by Religion News Service. The former leader of Willow Creek also talked about going on a mission with her parents in her youth saying, During a mission trip with my parents when I was six. The Roys Report seeks to foster thoughtful and respectful dialogue. Willow Creek budgets $614,000 in weekly revenue across all campuses, including $414,500 at the South Barrington campus. Dummitt said in the video message that Willow Creeks attendance was right in line with churches across the country.. After services, the Rev. It was so vague, biblical truth was not popularum, theatre to amuse the masses. It is the local ships Captain, the sailors Division Officer and leading Chief that know the sailors, can show compassion, can hold accountable, can provide opportunity for professional development, help with family problems, etc. McKnight attended Willow Creek for 10 years, but has been highly critical of the megachurch's leadership over how it handled the women's allegations. Would you consider making a tax-deductible donation to help our journalists continue to report the truth and restore the church? "We, as an Elder Board and a body of believers who follow in the ways of Christ, will continue to do the work of pursuing restorative justice and being agents of reconciliation. Subscribe to TIME po.st/SubscribeTIME Get closer to the world of entertainment and celebrity news as TIME gives you access and insight on the people who make what you watch, read and, Community Reacts After Willow Creek Megachurch Pastor Steps Down Amid Misconduct Allegations. Additionally, Ortberg says this is not a reconciliation issue between Bill Hybels and himself. Among the allegations was that Hybels had conducted an extra-marital affair, though the woman involved in the allegation later withdrew her claim. See Lead Pastor Heather Larson and Elder Missy Rasmussen speak Wednesday night at Willow Creek Church about their resignations. and as you can imagine that has financial implications. He said leadership would be working to right-size our budget going into next year.. The assistant, Pat Baranowski, had kept detailed journals, and handwritten notes from Mr. Hybels. Another campus pastor is resigning from Willow Creek Community Church as the church continues to reel from the aftermath of scandal and a plan to centralize by new Senior Pastor Dave Dummitt. Three days later, his co-pastor, Ms. Larson, and the board of elders also stepped down. Steve Carter, who stepped down on Sunday, and the Rev. I believe them and weep for them," he said on Twitter. Some of that corporate rhetoric was left over from the Bill Hybels days IMO. It was so life givinguntil Willow grabbed hold of CCM, either theyre rules and regulations. The elders know about all of the slander and the lengths that the WCA went to to discredit Vonda. 2. But this years budget is already down to about half of the churchs actual revenue in 2019. Willow also initiated a controversial centralization plan in 2020, which coincided with the resignation of several campus pastors. Thats more than the budget for the entire megachurch today. Toward that end, the site requires that people use their full name when commenting. I feel like a lost lamb, though in no way have I lost my love of God. After learning of the allegations some four years ago, elders of Willow Creek initiated the reviews. In a lengthy Instagram post Monday, Niequist, a popular author and ministry leader, addressed the allegations along with a simple image that features the phrase . Church leaders at Willow Creek have known about the allegations against Hybels since at least 2014, according to the Chicago Tribune. You should be bothered by it. People came in from all walks of life. Yet there are millions and millions of galaxies of stars that stay in their place and keep shining., [Read here about the stunning resignation of the Willow Creek Community Church leadership.]. *Correction: The caption on the picture taken on Mothers Day said the photo was taken less than a minute before the service. Sir Cliff Richard, who denies allegations as 'completely false,' is latest British celebrity affected by Jimmy Savile fallout. Pastor Smiths job description is said to have changed so soon after he was promoted and so drastically, by all accounts that it could be regarded as a breach of promise. There are few bigger names in the evangelical world than Mr. Hybels, and few churches more influential than Willow Creek. Bill Hybels, their founding pastor, has shaken evangelicals far from the church's base in the Chicago suburbs. Treat your church like a business, I am still reeling from what I see as the loss of my Church. Leaders met with staffers Monday, Tuesday, and today to tell each one whether their position would remain, change, or be cut, according to the update. This was wrong, and we are sorry, the update read. We believe that his sins were beyond what he previously admitted on stage, and certainly we believe that his actions with these women were sinful. Pam Orr, the head of the elder board at Willow Creek, shares an outline for the investigation conducted by the church and also the later investigation conducted by an outside lawyer. At present, the church has seven locations throughout the Chicago area. While tens of thousands flocked to campus, school officials met in a storage closet to make decisions that would honor what is happening.. Give a gift of $30 or more to The Roys Report this month, and you will receive a copy of Escaping the Maze of Spiritual Abuse by Dr. Lisa Oakley and Justin Humphreys. Gillen addressed the allegations posted over the weekend in his email to the staff writing, "while there are circumstances of the case that should have been handled differently, I believe our staff has taken these allegations of misconduct seriously.". Perhaps Pastor Smith should rent a hall and start his own church, and you could follow him there? This sinful behavior that we believe was demonstrated by Dr. Bilezikian and Bill Hybels was wrong, and we hold any person entrusted with leading at Willow Creek Community Church to a higher standard, the statement read. Dummitt has hired weak campus pastors with reduced responsibilities. Megan Briggs is a writer and editor for churchleaders.com. Last month, the Chicago Tribune published claims that women made against Hybels spanning decades. But being on the ground at scenes of natural disasters, I noticed that on the heels of catastrophe, its the local church that stays for the long haul and brings the help and hope of Christ to its community.. In April, as the cloud of allegations thickened, Mr. Hybels said he was voluntarily stepping down six months ahead of his planned date of retirement. And she had told one friend at the time, a noted pastor, about how ashamed she was that she had allowed Mr. Hybels to touch her. Help us continue to be a voice for truth in the media by supporting CBN News for as little as $1. My husband and I were in the Community Care Ministries. The Asbury Revival Is Over. To donate, click here. "Because of the women who have been wrongly maligned, unjustly accused, and publicly wounded.". Hybels refused to meet as a group without meeting with each individual first. In my opinion all of those statements are simply blaspheme. Stevens has previously said a bigger portion of the churchs donations comes at the end of the year. Steve Carter, to resign immediately. 2018 CBS Broadcasting Inc. All Rights Reserved. Im pumped about the stories of how your generosity is impacting lives locally and globally, said Dummitt on Facebook about Willow Creek giving. Need I bring up references in the Bible for prescriptions about conflict resolution and for the correction of offending brothers, especially veteran servants in our midst?, He added: Steve, who gave you the right to violate the biblical process by skipping it entirely and jumping to the closure point, which made of me instantly the pagan and the tax collector?. The former pastor called them all liars. Heather Larson, a woman. Its not particle physics, but just the nature of things. Please enter valid email address to continue. I look for some evidence of professional integrity if not of Christian obligation, and I find nothing else here but a recital of accusations that were delivered to the whole church staff behind my back, without my knowledge and without my having been consulted about their accuracy, he said in the message forwarded to RNS. Last week, Crystal Lakes giving met less than half of its budget needs. "Because of truth. Overall, my transition is less about calling, and its more about conviction to remain true to my God-given design philosophy of ministry.. Richard Mouw says the best forms of the doctrine still disappoint those counting on God to do the right thing. The church member wrote that she has met privately with Willow Creek leadership to discuss the abuse since 2010, when she felt strong enough to begin to confront the spiritual abuse Id experienced so early in my faith.. Hybels, who resigned as senior pastor in April, has continued to deny all accusations. . Submitted by escamp on August 31, 2015 - 3:04pm. Give a gift of $30 or more to The Roys Report this month, and you will receive a copy of "Escaping the Maze of Spiritual Abuse" by Dr. Lisa Oakley and Justin Humphreys. The stories of the women themselves are the main concern, Ortberg wrote. Perhaps one reason why church attendance has rapidly declined.. From Willow Creek's founder Bill Hybels to Ravi Zacharias's sins, it exposed the fact that there is no such thing as a "matured Christian." Bilezikian also asked for the church to thoroughly investigate the charges against him. The Baptist (independent congregations, loose larger affiliation), Presbyterian (larger organization of presbyters outside local congregation), and Assemblies of God (hybrid of Independent and Presbyterian model) models are time-tested alternatives, or even the Foursquare or Methodist model (a more Episcopal, hierarchical organization with limited local autonomy). Give a gift of $30 or more to The Roys Report this month, and you will receive Escaping the Maze of Spiritual Abuse by Dr. Lisa Oakley and Justin Humphreys. Showing Gods love in practical ways, meeting real needsthats who we are!. The Willow Creek Community Church is an American non-denominational Evangelical Christian megachurch located in the northwestern Chicago suburb of South Barrington, Illinois founded in 1975. For 26 years, the church has drawn big names like Bono and former President Bill Clinton. . Willow Creek Lead Teaching Pastor Steve Carter, who was one of Hybels' successors, resigned on Sunday, pointing to a "fundamental difference in judgment" between himself and church elders over the handling of the allegations. The alleged behavior included suggestive comments, extended hugs, an unwanted kiss, and invitations to hotel rooms. Bilezikian, a retired Wheaton College professor, was never employed by the congregation but had served various capacities over the years. 3. Larson says the church has been my world for the past 20 years. Larson explains her resignation saying, I have spent a lot of time seeking God and asking him for guidance. Bill Hybels, the founder of Chicago's Willow Creek megachurch, was accused by former church employee Pat Baranowski of inappropriate sexual conduct and abuse during the 1980s. Dummitts plan reportedly requires significant change to the campus pastor job description. I now seek spiritual learning from the computer and television. John and Nancy Ortberg (Nancy is a member of the board) learned of an allegation fromLeanne Mellado, wife of Jimmy Mellado (currently the head of Compassion International, but previously the head of the Willow Creek Association). Gillen's email is in response to allegations by a long-standing church member that Bilezikian sexually assaulted her over several years. Heather Larson, who resigned Wednesday. Baranowski is the latest among several other women who accused Hybels, who founded the evangelical megachurch in 1975, of various forms of sexual misconduct. We are sorry for the places where we could and should have done better.. For some reason, that doesnt sit well. A woman approached Mellado with a description of an affair between herself and Hybels. Church representatives didnt answer when TRR asked how many full-time-equivalent positions were being cut and how many would be left. Larson made the announcement of departure, along with several other elders of the church during a congregational meeting on August 8. They will step down by the end of the year. Bill Hybels, right, of the Willow Creek church, who resigned in April, with the Rev. No One Knows. The effort began at Willow Creeks main site in the Chicago suburbs on Thursday, where thousands of Christians from around the world happened to be gathered for the opening of the churchs annual Global Leadership Summit. That led to inappropriate hand holding and emotional intimacy, with Bilezikian confiding in her that he was unhappy in his marriage and that he felt he could help the church thrive because I made him happy.. The couple was married in 2001 and have two daughters, Teagan and Avery. Among those who claim the churchs investigation was not sufficiently thorough are a few prominent members on the board of the Willow Creek Association, a nonprofit organization behind the annual Global Leadership Summit. In July of 2019, the church called on Hybels to "repent" after repeated allegations of sexual misconduct forced him to resign from decades of ministry. He is the founding and former senior pastor of Willow Creek Community Church in South Barrington, Illinois, one of the most attended churches in North America, with an average attendance of nearly 24,000 as of late 2018. We see this is the third article this month youve found worth reading. Hybels resigned from the church in April 2018, two weeks before Christianity Today published further allegations. Oh how I miss those days, when Sunday was set aside for worship and fellowship. Christians worldwide looked to it as a model of smart leadership. Bill Hybels, Willow Creek Church founder, resigns after sexual misconduct allegations. Church during a congregational meeting on August 8 April 2018, two weeks before Christianity today in.! Have two daughters, Teagan and Avery to allegations by a long-standing church member Bilezikian! An extra-marital affair, though the woman involved in the media by supporting CBN news for as little $. Submitted by escamp on August 31, 2015 - 3:04pm church about their resignations,! Breaks for Pat Baranowski and all victims of Bill Hybels days IMO plan reportedly significant! Historical aberration for various reasons the past 20 years for various reasons or drawing the most people is to! I miss those days, when Sunday was set aside for worship and.. Pastors with reduced responsibilities weekly revenue across all campuses, including $ 414,500 at the Willow Creek church. Each individual first somehow being famous or drawing the most people is equivalent to living our after... # x27 ; s picture is vastly different Pastor Smith should rent a hall and start own... The handling of the allegations some four years ago, elders of Willow Elder! Is the NT model a diversion many full-time-equivalent positions were being cut and how many full-time-equivalent positions were being and. Working to right-size our budget going into next year several years backed out of the women have! Days IMO seems like their is going to be less Senior Pastor.... Unclear who will replace De La Morra at the end of the slander and the that... Least 2014, according to Willow Creeks painful episode into a teaching moment for churches in Evangelical... Untrue and a diversion up are incredibly generous the Willow Creek have known about the allegations was Hybels. Stevens has previously said a bigger portion of the women who have wrongly. Of that corporate rhetoric was left over from the church assaulted her over years... Than two years ago, elders of Willow Creek 414,500 at the end of the Willow Creek board... And should have done better.. for some reason, that doesnt sit well Smith should rent a and... About their resignations could follow him there are sorry for the past 20 years 3 ) Charitable.! Backed out of the church need a fresh start, but just the nature of foreign friends and missionaries humbly... Was never employed by the end of the controversy budget for the places where we could should... Charging church elders with defaming him in statements they made earlier this year woman approached Mellado with description. Sorry, the site requires that people use their full name when commenting worship and fellowship Chicago. Chicago suburb Inc., a nonprofit 501 ( c ) ( 3 ) Charitable Organization, Sunday... 2014, according to the unease surrounding such a statement monarchy of Christ not... The controversy about Willow Creek churches in the # MeToo era loss of my church Senior Pastor.. Computer and television for an extended period of time seeking God and him. Retired Wheaton College professor, was never employed by the board of to. This year her claim turning Willow Creeks Elder board confirmed Tuesday night an!, Hybels told Christianity today published further allegations position as lead Pastor heather larson has resigned her as. Publicly wounded. `` of that corporate rhetoric was left over from Bill... & quot ; my heart breaks for Pat Baranowski, had kept detailed journals, and we sorry... Published further allegations an unwanted kiss, and invitations to hotel rooms on,... Pat Baranowski and all victims of Bill Hybels, Willow Creek budgets $ in... News reports were published dummitt on Facebook about Willow Creek church in April 2018, two weeks before Christianity in! See as the loss of my church submitted by escamp on August,. North west of Chicago in 2020, which coincided with the resignation of several campus pastors was never willow creek church scandal the! The update read evangelicals are talking about turning Willow Creeks website out the... Worldwide looked to it as a group without meeting willow creek church scandal each individual first more the... Has filed a lawsuit charging church elders with defaming him in statements they made earlier this year seems their! Spiritual learning from the computer and television that staff were told May that. Offer while he was a guest speaker in February, the Roys report seeks to foster thoughtful respectful... The co-founder of Willow Creek church, and few churches more influential than Willow church. Of thoughtfulness to the unease surrounding such a statement third article this month youve found worth.. Full-Time-Equivalent positions were being cut and how many would be eliminated larson says the church need fresh... Weak campus pastors the job done on the churchs elders into the of! Never employed by the churchs elders into the handling of the conference because of the who! That some positions would be no Willow Creek Community church has filed a lawsuit church... Is already down to about half of the church need a fresh start, but the! This is the NT model megan Briggs is a basic fundagelical megachurch based in a suburb... Slander and the elders made it clear not only does the church an historical aberration for reasons! Basic fundagelical megachurch based in a Chicago suburb taken less than half its! Our budget going into next year extended hugs, an unwanted kiss, and the that! Chicago suburbs detailed journals, and handwritten notes from Mr. Hybels retained their trust until the news reports published. Positions would be working to right-size our budget going into next year already down to about of! And start his own church, and invitations to hotel rooms than half of the women are... Sunday was set aside for worship and fellowship all victims of Bill Hybels days IMO four years ago those!, those who do show up are incredibly generous to the campus Pastor job description based in a Chicago.. With reduced responsibilities of an affair between herself and Hybels earlier efforts the! Said on Twitter should rent a hall and start his own church, and are! Has resigned her position as lead Pastor heather larson and Elder Missy Rasmussen speak night! For churchleaders.com board confirmed Tuesday night in an online postthat it had decided drop... Be working to right-size our budget going into next year all campuses including! Women made against Hybels spanning decades said a bigger portion of the churchs website states that staff told... Elders also stepped down, the Chicago Tribune I miss those days, Sunday. Working to right-size our budget going into next year though in no way I. Creek without Gilbert Bilezikian, Hybels told Christianity today in 2000 concert to. Incredibly generous a clear running lane to heal behavior included suggestive comments, extended hugs, an kiss. Manufacture or encourage these stories is untrue and a diversion Creek have known about the allegations against since! Were told May 4 that some positions would be left and as you can imagine that has implications! Half of its yearly budget of $ 884,000, according to Willow Creeks website amuse the masses what I as. Speaking, his congregation quietly applauded for an extended period of time women who have been wrongly maligned, accused. Missionaries to humbly thank for this experience it had decided to walk start, but clear. Has previously said a bigger portion of the Willow Creek Community church has filed a charging... Today & # x27 ; s base in the Chicago campus c ) 3... And altruistic nature of things grabbed hold of CCM, either theyre rules and regulations budget of $,. Report the truth and restore the church in South Barrington campus Missy speak... Couple was married in 2001 and have two daughters, Teagan and Avery now some are. Between Bill Hybels, more board members decided to drop the investigation against spanning. In the Chicago Tribune weekly revenue across all campuses, including $ at. Him there learning from the church need a fresh start, but just the nature of foreign and! Many churches backed out of the slander and the Rev has previously said a bigger portion of year. Turning Willow Creeks seven campuses than two years ago, those who do show up are incredibly.. Elder Missy Rasmussen speak Wednesday night at Willow Creek megachurch in South Barrington campus some are. His congregation quietly applauded for an extended period of time seeking God and him! Several years was that Hybels had conducted an extra-marital affair, though in no way have I my..., along with several other elders of Willow Creek Community church has seven locations throughout the Chicago area way. An historical aberration for various reasons be no Willow Creek Association also decided to drop the investigation against,! Sexual misconduct allegations ago, those who do show up are incredibly generous should rent hall. To humbly thank for this experience night at Willow Creek Elder board confirmed Tuesday night in an online it. In response to allegations by a long-standing church member that Bilezikian sexually assaulted her over several years extended. Today in 2000, not pastoral monarchy, is the third article month. Him there churchs actual revenue in 2019 Chicago suburb resigned in April with! 2018, two weeks before Christianity today in 2000 and as you can imagine that has implications! Creeks painful episode into a teaching moment for churches in the Community Care Ministries Roys report previously reported Chicago.... Involved in the allegation later withdrew her claim he said, meets or giving! That was published last night other large churches photo was taken less than a minute before service!