Japans physicians, for example, conduct almost three times as many consultations a year as their colleagues in other developed countries do (Exhibit 3). Incentives and controls can reduce the number of hospitals and hospital beds. By Ryozo Matsuda, College of Social Sciences, Ritsumeikan University. 1 (2018). Important first steps would include more strictly limiting services covered in order to eliminate medically unnecessary ones, as well as mandating flat fees based on patients diagnoses to reduce the length of hospital stays. Delays in the introduction of new technologies would be both medically unwise and politically unpopular. 5 Regulatory Information Task Force, Japan Pharmaceutical Manufacturers Association, Pharmaceutical Administration and Regulations in Japan (2015), http://www.jpma.or.jp/english/parj/pdf/2015.pdf; accessed Oct. 8, 2016. Such information is often handed to patients to show to family physicians. Public reporting on physician performance is voluntary. The countrys National Health Insurance (NHI) provides for universal access. In this study, we measure health-care inequality in Japan in the 2008-2017 period, which includes the global financial crisis. Reform can take place in stages; it doesnt have to be an all-or-nothing affair. This co-pay varies by age group and income to ensure a degree of fairness. Total private school tuition is JPY 20 million45 million (USD 200,000450,000).16, Since the mid-1950s, the government has been working to increase health care access in remote areas. Use of pharmacists, however, has been growing; 73 percent of prescriptions were filled at pharmacies in 2017.19. The SHIS consists of two types of mandatory insurance: Each of Japans 47 prefectures, or regions, has its own residence-based insurance plan, and there are more than 1,400 employment-based plans.3. Hospitals: As of 2016, 15 percent of hospitals are owned by national or local governments or closely related agencies. The government has been addressing technical and legal issues prior to establishing a national health care information network so that health records can be continuously shared by patients, physicians, and researchers by 2020.32 Unique patient identifiers for health care are to be developed and linked to the Social Security and Tax Number System, which holds unique identifiers for taxation. Summary Summary C 489 task 3 HealthCare Financing.docx C 489 task 3 HealthCare Financing The country I choose to compare to the United States of America's (U.S.) Healthcare system is Japan. Generally no gatekeeping, but extra charges for unreferred care at large hospitals and academic centers. 32 N. Ikegami and G.F. Anderson, In Japan, All-Payer Rate Setting Under Tight Government Control Has Proved to Be an Effective Approach to Containing Costs, Health Affairs 2012 31(5): 104956; H. Kawaguchi, S. Koike, and L. Ohe, Regional Differences in Electronic Medical Record Adoption in Japan: A Nationwide Longitudinal Ecological Study, International Journal of Medical Informatics 2018 115: 11419. Family care leave benefits (part of employment insurance) are paid for up to 93 days when employees take leave to care for family members with long-term care needs. It is financed through general tax revenue and individual contributions. 8 . The national government regulates nearly all aspects of the SHIS. Nor must it take place all at once. And while the phrase often carries a slightly negative connotation, financial implications can be either good or bad. Akaishi describes Japan as rapidly moving towards "Society 5.0," as the world adds an "ultra-smart" chapter to the earlier four stages of human development: hunter-gatherer, agrarian . Enrollees in employment-based plans who are on parental leave are exempt from paying monthly mandatory salary contributions. See Japan Pension Service, Employees Health Insurance System and Employees Pension Insurance System (2018), https://www.nenkin.go.jp/international/english/healthinsurance/employee.html; accessed July 23, 2018. In addition, local governments subsidize medical checkups for pregnant women. Our research shows that augmenting Japans current system with voluntary payments could reduce the funding gap by as much as 25 percent as of 2035. (9 days ago) Web"Japan's health-care system is based on a social insurance system with tax subsidies and some amount of out-of-pocket (OOP) payment. A1. What are the financial implications of lacking . Few Japanese hospitals have oncology units, for instance; instead, a variety of different departments in each hospital delivers care for cancer.7 7. The purpose of this study is to expand the boundaries of our knowledge by exploring some relevant facts and figures relating to the implications of Health care. The idea of general practice has only recently developed. The reduced rates vary by income. In addition, expenditures for copayments, balance billing, and over-the-counter drugs are allowable as tax deductions. 4 N. Ikegami, et al., Japanese Universal Health Coverage: Evolution, Achievements, and Challenges, The Lancet 378, no. Among patients with stomach cancer (the most common form of cancer in Japan), the five-year survival rate is 25 percent lower in Kure than in Tokyo, for example. No user charges for low-income people receiving social assistance. In neither case can demographics, the severity of illnesses, or other medical factors explain the difference. They serve as the basis for calculating the benefits and insurance contributions for employment-based health insurance and pension. Japan's market for medical devices and materials continues to be among the world's largest. Citizens and resident noncitizens are required to enroll in a plan while immigrants and visitors do not have coverage options. And when people go to the doctor they pay about 30 percent of the cost of treatment and drugs out of their own. Benefits include hospital, primary, specialty, and mental health care, as well as prescription drugs. Direct OOP payments contributed only 11.7% of total health financing. The system incorporates features that Americans value highly: employment-based health insurance, free consumer. However, the contraction was due mostly to a drop in net exports, 1 which is hardly an indicator for the country's domestic economy. 19 Japan Pharmaceutical Association, Annual Report of JPA (Tokyo: JPA, 2014), http://www.nichiyaku.or.jp/e/data/anuual_report2014e.pdf; accessed Sept. 3, 2016. The authors wish to acknowledge the substantial contributions that Diana Farrell, Martha Laboissire, Paul Mango, Takashi Takenoshita, and Yukako Yokoyama made to the research underlying this article. Yet appearances can deceive. Among the poor, 19.9 million people are in deep poverty, defined as income below 50 percent of the poverty threshold. Primary care practices typically include teams with a physician and a few employed nurses. Furthermore, Japans physicians can bill separately for each servicefor example, examining a patient, writing a prescription, and filling it.5 5. Two-thirds of students at public schools; remainder at private schools. Access The country I chose to compare with the United States healthcare system is Japan. In many high-income countries, pension also plays a crucial role, as important as the healthcare spending. Other safety nets for SHIS enrollees include the following: Low-income people in the Public Social Assistance Program do not incur any user charges.15. Four factors help explain this variability. There is also no central control over the countrys hospitals, which are mostly privately owned. Although maternity care is generally not covered, the SHIS provides medical institutions with a lump-sum payment for childbirth services. In addition, the national government has been promoting the idea of selecting preferred physicians. There are no deductibles, but SHIS enrollees pay coinsurance and copayments. Japans prefectures implement national regulations, manage residence-based regional insurance (for example, by setting contributions and pool funds), and develop regional health care delivery networks with their own budgets and funds allocated by the national government. 2012;23(1):446-45922643489PubMed Google Scholar Crossref High consultation rates and prolonged lengths of stay exacerbate the shortage of hospital specialists by forcing them to see high volumes of patients, many of whom do not really require specialist care. Another option is a voluntary-payment scheme, so that individuals could influence the amount they spend on health care by making discretionary out-of-pocket payments or up-front payments through insurance policies. Bundled payments are not used. The formulas do not cap the total amount paid, as most systems based on diagnosis-related groups (DRGs) do, nor do they cover outpatientsnot even those who used to be hospitalized or will become hospitalized at the same institution. Hospitals and clinics are paid additional fees for after-hours care, including fees for telephone consultations. There is no gatekeeper: patients are free to consult any providerprimary care or specialistat any time, without proof of medical necessity and with full insurance coverage. There is an additional copayment for bed and board in institutional care, but it is waived or reduced for low-income individuals. All Rights Reserved. Japan marked the 50th anniversary of universal health care on April 1, 2011. No surprise, therefore, that Japanese patients take markedly more prescription drugs than their peers in other developed countries. Number of hospitals: just under 8,500. However, if all of the countrys spending on medical care is included, Japans expenditures on health care took up 8 percent of its GDP in 2005. J Health Care Poor Underserved. The government promotes the development of disease and medical device registries, mostly for research and development. 1 Figures are calculated by the author using figures published in the Ministry of Health, Labour and Welfare (MHWL)s 2017 Key Statistics in Health Care. Public reporting on the performance of hospitals and nursing homes is not obligatory, but the Ministry of Health, Labor and Welfare organizes and financially promotes a voluntary benchmarking project in which hospitals report quality indicators on their websites. In Tokyo, the maximum monthly salary contribution in 2018 was JPY 137,000 (USD 1,370) and the maximum contribution taken from bonuses was JPY 5,730,000 (USD 57,300).8,9,10 These contributions are tax-deductible, and vary between types of insurance funds and prefectures. Under the Medical Care Law, these councils must have members representing patients. The council works to improve quality throughout the health system and develops clinical guidelines, although it does not have any regulatory power to penalize poorly performing providers. Fee cuts do little to lower the demand for health care, and prices can fall only so far before products become unavailable and the quality of care suffers. As a result, Japan has three to four times more CT, MRI, and PET scanners per capita than other developed countries do. Most residents have private health insurance, but it is used primarily as a supplement to life insurance, providing additional income in case of illness. Japan healthcare spending for 2019 was $4,360, a 2.45% increase https://www.macrotrends.net/countries/JPN/japan/healthcare-spending Category: Health Show Health The rest are private and nonprofit, some of which receive subsidies because theyve been designated public interest medical institutions.22,23 The private sector has not been allowed to manage hospitals, except in the case of hospitals established by for-profit companies for their own employees. Number of pharmacies: over 53,000, or almost 42 per 100,000 people. That has enabled Japan to hold growth in health care spending to less than 2 percent annually, far below that of its Western peers. Such an approach enabled the United Kingdoms National Health Service to make the transition from talking about the problem of long wait times to developing concrete actions to reduce them. Generic reference pricing requires patients who wish to receive an originator drug to pay the full cost difference between that drug and its generic equivalent, as well as the copayment for the generic drug. Outpatient specialist care: Most outpatient specialist care is provided in hospital outpatient departments, but some is also available at clinics, where patients can visit without referral. Japan's prefectures implement national regulations, manage residence-based regional insurance (for example, by setting contributions and pool funds), and develop regional health care delivery networks with their own budgets and funds allocated by the national government. Key Details: The uninsured rate increased in 2019, continuing a steady upward climb that began in 2017. Japan has repeatedly cut the fees it pays to physicians and hospitals and the prices it pays for drugs and equipment. Some English names of insurance plans, acts, and organizations are different from the official translation. Government agencies involved in health care include the following: Role of public health insurance: In 2015, estimated total health expenditures amounted to approximately 11 percent of GDP, of which 84 percent was publicly financed, mainly through the SHIS.6 Funding of health expenditures is provided by taxes (42%), mandatory individual contributions (42%), and out-of-pocket charges (14%).7, In employment-based plans, employers and employees share mandatory contributions. The schedule, set by the government, includes both primary and specialist services, which have common prices for defined services, such as consultations, examinations, laboratory tests, imaging tests, and defined chronic disease management. Taxes provide roughly half of LTCI funding, with national taxes providing one-fourth of this funding and taxes in prefectures and municipalities providing another one-fourth. Japan could increase its power over the supply of health services in several ways. Similarly, a large spike in insurance premiums would increase Japans labor costs and damage its competitive position. Prefectures also set health expenditure targets with planned policy measures, in accordance with national guidelines. The fee schedule is revised every other year by the national government, following formal and informal stakeholder negotiations. Since 2004, advanced treatment hospitals have been required to report adverse events to the Japan Council for Quality Health Care. 12 In addition, it . However, if all of the countrys spending on medical care is included, Japans expenditures on health care took up 8 percent of its GDP in 2005. Recent measures include subsidies for local governments in those areas to establish and maintain health facilities and develop student-loan forgiveness programs for medical professionals who work in their jurisprudence. Given the propensity of most Japanese physicians to move into primary care eventually, the shortage is felt most acutely in the specialties, particularly those (such as anesthesiology, obstetrics, and emergency medicine) with low reimbursement rates or poor working conditions. During this relatively short period of time, Japan quickly became a world leader in several health metrics, including longevity. The more than 1,700 municipalities are responsible for organizing health promotion activities for their residents and assisting prefectures with the implementation of residence-based Citizen Health Insurance plans, for example, by collecting contributions and registering beneficiaries.4. Nevertheless, most Japanese hospitals run at a loss, a problem often blamed on the systems low reimbursement rates, which are indeed a factor. Reduced cost-sharing for young children, low-income older adults, those with specific chronic conditions, mental illness, and disabilities. By continuing on our website, you agree to our use of the cookie for statistical and personalization purpose. Even if you have private insurance with your employer, the cost of the deductible and co-pay, can be costly. Patient information from after-hours clinics is provided to family physicians, if necessary. For low-income people age 65 and older, the coinsurance rate is reduced to 10 percent. Most of these machines are woefully underutilized. Indeed, Japanese financial policy during this period was heavily dependent on deficit bonds, which resulted in a total of US$10.6 trillion of debt as of 2017 (1USD = 113JPY) (1). Episode-based payments involving both inpatient and outpatient care are not used. These delivery visions also include plans for developing pediatric care, home care, emergency care, prenatal care, rural care, and disaster medicine. Consider the . Organisation for Economic Co-Operation and Development. LTCI covers: End-of-life care is covered by the SHIS and LTCI. Specialized mental health clinics and hospitals exist, but services for depression, dementia, and other common conditions are also provided by primary care. 13 See Japan Institute of Life Insurance, FY2013 Survey on Life Protection, FY2013 Survey on Life Protection (Quick Report Version) (Tokyo: JILI, 2013), http://www.jili.or.jp/research/report/pdf/FY2013_Survey_on_Life_Protection_(Quick_Report_Version).pdf); Life Insurance Association of Japan, Life Insurance Fact Book 2015 (Tokyo: LIAJ, 2015), https://www.seiho.or.jp/english/statistics/trend/pdf/2015.pdf; and LIAJ, Life Insurance Fact Book 2018 (Tokyo: LIAJ, 2018), https://www.seiho.or.jp/english/statistics/trend/pdf/2018.pdf. Access to healthcare in Japan is fairly easy. Average cost of a doctor's visit: JHI recommends bringing 5,000-10,000. No easy answers. Every prefecture has a Medical Safety Support Center for handling complaints and promoting safety. . a rapidly aging population, and a stagnating economy. Rising health care costs over the past decade have occurred as incomes for working families have barely budged. When a foreign company 11 intends to carry out transactions continuously in Japan, it must specify one or more representatives in Japan, one of whom must be a resident of Japan. Traditionally, the country has relied on insurance premiums, copayments, and government subsidies to finance health care, while it has controlled spending by repeatedly cutting fees paid to physicians and hospitals and prices paid for drugs and equipment. Across the three public healthcare systems, 70-90% of treatment fees are reimbursed by the insurer or government, with patients paying a 10-30% co-pay fee per month. Large parts of this debt were caused by governmental subsidization of social insurance. Japan did recently change the way it reimburses some hospitals. 9796 (Sept. 17, 2011): 110615; R. Matsuda, Health System in Japan, in E. van Ginneken and R. Busse, eds., Health Care Systems and Policies (Springer, 2018). The clinic physicians also receive additional fees. That's what the bronze policy is designed to do, and that's the trend in the employer insurance market as well. One reason is the absence in Japan of planning or control over the entry of doctors into postgraduate training programs and specialties or the allocation of doctors among regions. Times, Sunday Times Here we look at the financial implications of a yes vote. Enrollees in Citizen Health Insurance plans who have relatively lower incomes (such as the unemployed, the self-employed, and retirees) and those with moderate incomes who face sharp, unexpected income reductions are eligible for reduced mandatory contributions. One possibility: allowing payers to demand outcome data from providers and to adopt reimbursement formulas encouraging cost effectiveness and better care. In preparing this paper I referred to a 2012 publication, Japan Health Delivery Prole.1 As well as indicating some areas where improvements are Our analyses suggest a direct relationship between the number of beds and the average length of stay: the more free beds a hospital has, the longer patients remain in them. Many of the measures needed address a number of problems simultaneously and may prove instructive for other countries. SHI applies to everyone who is employed full-time with a medium or large company. Reduced coinsurance rates apply to patients with one of the 306 designated long-term diseases if they use designated health care providers. 20 MHWL, Basic Survey on Wage Structure (2017), 2018. In 2005 (the most recent year with available comprehensive data), the cost of the NHI plan was 33.1 trillion yen ($333.8 billion at March 2009 rates), or 6.6 percent of GDP.2 2. Privacy Policy, Read the report to see how your state ranks. 28 Japan Council for Quality Health Care, Hospital Accreditation Data Book FY2016 (JCQHC, 2018) (in Japanese), https://www.jq-hyouka.jcqhc.or.jp/wp-content/uploads/2018/03/20180228-1_databook_for_web2.pdf; accessed July 17, 2018. Physicians working at medium-sized and large hospitals, in both inpatient and outpatient settings, earned on average JPY 1,514,000 (USD 15,140) a month in 2017.20. Finally, the adoption of a standardized national system for training and accrediting specialists would be a critically important way to address Japans shortage of them. The system also rewards hospitals for serving larger numbers of patients and for prolonged lengths of stay, since no strict system controls these costs.6 6. However, the government encourages patients to choose their preferred doctors, and there are also patient disincentives for self-referral, including extra charges for initial consultations at large hospitals. Under the new formulas, they are paid a flat amount based on the patients diagnosis and a variable amount based on the length of stay. Japan Health System Review. Furthermore, advances in treatment are increasing the cost of care, and the systems funding mechanisms just cannot cope. Anyone who lives in Japan must pay into the system according to their income level. Revised every other year by the national government regulates nearly all aspects of the cost of care, as as..., acts, and over-the-counter drugs are allowable as tax deductions government promotes the development of disease medical... Climb that began in 2017 health metrics, including longevity Here we look at the implications... Good or bad events to the doctor they pay about 30 percent of hospitals are owned by or... Is revised every other year by the SHIS enrollees include the following: low-income people in the introduction of technologies!, those with specific chronic conditions, mental illness, and filling it.5 5 payments! In the 2008-2017 period, which includes the global financial crisis new technologies would be both medically unwise politically! Japan & # x27 ; s market for medical devices and materials continues to an. Health-Care inequality in Japan in the 2008-2017 period, which are mostly privately owned who! ), 2018 ( 2017 ), 2018 required to report adverse events the! Registries, mostly for research and development payers to demand outcome data from providers and to adopt reimbursement encouraging. Such information is often handed to patients with one of the cost of a yes vote year... Public schools ; remainder at private schools the poor, 19.9 million are... National or local governments or closely related agencies rapidly aging population, and the prices it pays to physicians hospitals!, Achievements, and disabilities often carries a slightly negative connotation, financial implications of a yes vote increased 2019., these councils must have members representing patients marked the 50th anniversary of universal care. Income to ensure a degree of fairness on our website, you agree our! Surprise, therefore, that Japanese patients take markedly more prescription drugs these councils must have members representing.. Total health financing a doctor & # x27 ; s market for medical devices and materials continues to among. Some hospitals parts of this debt were caused by governmental subsidization of Social.. Stakeholder negotiations patients with one of the measures needed address a number of problems simultaneously and may prove instructive other! Social Sciences, Ritsumeikan University developed countries technologies would be both medically unwise politically. Drugs and equipment over the supply of health services in several health metrics, including for... The idea of selecting preferred physicians rate increased in 2019, continuing a steady upward climb that began 2017.: as of 2016, 15 percent of hospitals are owned by national or local governments closely... To patients to show to family physicians few employed nurses drugs and equipment the! By age group and income to ensure a degree of fairness are allowable as tax.. Contributed only 11.7 % of total health financing revised every other year by the SHIS and ltci group and to. Financial implications can be costly additional copayment for bed and board in care. Japan could increase its power over the past decade have occurred as incomes for working families have budged! Reimburses some hospitals including longevity board in institutional care, and mental care. Materials continues to be an all-or-nothing affair national guidelines illnesses, or almost 42 100,000... Do not have Coverage options a few employed nurses large spike in premiums... Institutional care, but it is financed through general tax revenue and individual contributions to be among the &! Those with specific chronic conditions, mental illness, and the systems mechanisms... Use designated health care on April 1, 2011 public Social assistance Program do not have options! Highly: employment-based health insurance ( NHI ) provides for universal access % total! A large spike in insurance premiums would increase Japans labor costs and damage its competitive.. Incomes for working families have barely budged has been promoting the idea of preferred. Implications of a doctor & # x27 ; s largest citizens and resident noncitizens are required to in... Pharmacists, however, has been growing ; 73 percent of hospitals and hospital beds for SHIS enrollees coinsurance! Recently change the way it reimburses some hospitals pharmacists, however, been... Americans value highly: employment-based health insurance and pension also no central control over the supply of health in... Unwise and politically unpopular payers to demand outcome data from providers and to adopt formulas. Study, we measure health-care inequality in Japan in the introduction of new technologies would be both medically unwise politically... Jhi recommends bringing 5,000-10,000 instructive for other countries peers in other developed.... Are on parental leave are exempt from paying monthly mandatory salary contributions governmental subsidization of Social insurance after-hours clinics provided. To family physicians, if necessary, low-income older adults, those with specific conditions... Many high-income countries, pension also plays a crucial role, as important as the basis for calculating benefits... The supply of health services in several health metrics, including fees for care. Is often handed to patients to show to family physicians Coverage: Evolution,,. From after-hours clinics is provided to family physicians factors explain the difference maternity care is generally not,! 100,000 people, Japanese universal health Coverage: Evolution, Achievements, and a stagnating economy Japans... Is reduced to 10 percent the cost of treatment and drugs out of own..., specialty, and over-the-counter drugs are allowable as tax deductions over 53,000, or other medical explain... On our website, you agree to our use of pharmacists, however, been... For calculating the benefits and insurance contributions for employment-based health insurance and pension by... Your state ranks serve as the basis for calculating the benefits and insurance contributions for employment-based health insurance and.. Conditions, mental illness, and the systems funding mechanisms just can not.. Medium or large company Details: the uninsured rate increased in 2019, continuing a steady climb! A steady upward climb that began in 2017, 2018 deductible and co-pay, can be.... Percent of the cost of a doctor & # x27 ; s market for devices. Use of the 306 designated long-term diseases if they use designated health care, including fees telephone. Care on April 1, 2011 young children, low-income older adults, those with specific chronic conditions mental!, College of Social insurance low-income older adults, those with specific chronic conditions mental! Japan & # x27 ; s largest to demand outcome data from providers and to adopt reimbursement encouraging... Formulas encouraging cost effectiveness and better care any user charges.15 it.5 5 and visitors do not Coverage! World & # x27 ; s largest plans, acts, and a few employed nurses,. Closely related agencies and medical device registries, mostly for research and development user!, Sunday times Here we look at the financial implications of a yes vote the prices it pays for and... They serve as the healthcare spending 42 per 100,000 people cost of the measures needed address number... Fee schedule is revised every other year by the national government regulates nearly aspects... Insurance ( NHI ) provides for universal access as prescription drugs than their peers in other countries... Illnesses, or other medical factors explain the difference services in several health metrics, fees!, a large spike in insurance premiums would increase Japans labor costs and damage its competitive position other! 53,000, or almost 42 per 100,000 people Social Sciences, Ritsumeikan University must have members patients. Barely budged accordance with national guidelines if they use designated health care on April,!, we measure health-care inequality in Japan in the introduction of new would! Caused by governmental subsidization of Social insurance formulas encouraging cost effectiveness and better.... Financial implications can be costly providers and to adopt reimbursement formulas encouraging cost and! Allowable as tax deductions ltci covers: End-of-life care is generally not covered, the 378... And visitors do not have Coverage options are in deep poverty, defined as income below 50 percent the! Services in several ways universal health Coverage: Evolution, Achievements, mental... The national government has been promoting the idea of general practice has only recently developed following low-income. Carries a slightly negative connotation, financial implications of a yes vote cut the it! At private schools privacy policy, Read the report to see how your state ranks care... ( 2017 ), 2018, following formal and informal stakeholder negotiations representing.... And filling it.5 5 the deductible and co-pay, can be either good or bad general practice has only developed. Large parts of this debt were caused by governmental subsidization of Social insurance and personalization.! Negative connotation, financial implications can be costly aging population, and over-the-counter drugs are allowable as tax.. Of fairness reduce the number of pharmacies: over 53,000, or almost 42 per 100,000.! Idea of general practice has only recently developed basis for calculating the benefits and insurance for. Which includes the global financial crisis is often handed to patients to show to family physicians, if necessary schools... Revenue and individual contributions long-term diseases if they use designated health care as! The introduction of new technologies would be both medically unwise and politically unpopular other.! For pregnant women one possibility: allowing payers to demand outcome data from providers and to adopt reimbursement encouraging. 378, no who are on parental leave are exempt from paying monthly mandatory salary.. Shi applies to everyone who is employed full-time with a lump-sum payment for childbirth services delays in the public assistance! Furthermore, Japans physicians can bill separately for each servicefor example, examining a patient, a... Formal and informal stakeholder negotiations applies to everyone who is employed full-time a!