Although factory ammo is optimized for 6" barrels, a recipe for rifle length . What does the group think or better have had experience with Speer 135 grain Gold Dot in a SP101 357 Magnum with a 2.25"barrel. Id be curious to see a similar comparison with 44 Magnum / Special. These velocity gains translate into twice the bullet energy and half as much drop out to 100 yards. Velocity by barrel length for 5.56x45mm NATO cartridge. The first of the Magnum pistol cartridges, it was a big hit. This information has been sourced from Ballistics by the Inch. That suggests you will get different terminal performance firing the same cartridge out of your revolver and your rifle. Such performance leaves the 10mm Auto, .38 Super and .357 SIG in the dirt by comparison. As it turned out, the best part was loading and shooting lead-alloy bullets in the fast-cycling Lightning. For example, the Uberti shot Sierra 125-grain JHC bullets 818 fps faster than a revolver with the same 22.0 grains of Power Pro 300-MP. Gold Dot. Ruger SP101, 3-inch barrel. Terril has a soft spot for ballistics testing, pocket pistols, and French rifles. Mark also said that many lawman carried a .45 revolver and a rifle caliber Winchester lever gun. data is provided purely for entertainment purposes - to better facilitate arguments
As a result, this page will act as an extra copy of that valuable data. When this happens, the bullet usually breaks apart, loses its mass and under-penetrates. Many firearms have been chambered in .357 Mag. This load is equivalent to a .38 Special +P. Customer experience was, and still is, the primary focus, a key to the firms longevity and success. I want a levergun in .357 mag so bad, Im waiting for a production lever gun in .357 Max, got money on the table. Wish I still had mine. The racetrack is full of obstacles like the red cube. That will go clean through a horse at 100 yards and kill whatever is hiding behind it. Chuck Hawks rifle ballistics table Despite the fact there is little commercial production for the .357 Remington maximum, the cartridge is well liked by hunters who understand the velocities, energy, and recoil it produces makes for a very efficient and manageable cartridge. For .357 mag, generally the longer the better - that said, big differences exist between 2 to 6 inch lengths which would be most common, but .357 magnum gains velocity in most loading all the way out to 18-20" carbine barrels. Remember that a suppressor will increase muzzle velocity somewhat. Our .30-30: an early-1990s Winchester Model 1894 Trapper with a 16.5 barrel. This is because the longer the propellant has had time to burn, the more of its maximum effect on the projectile can be utilized. The difference between a 2.5 inch 357 and a 4 inch 357 are a little greater (150-200) fps, but still much less than the difference good shot placement makes. Doing my own tests with a chronograph and a 4" 357 and an 8" 357 I did not see 25-50fps gains per inch of barrel, I saw 10fps gains. It has been sourced from the Ballistics by the Inch website. Something like an AR-15 in the 8-inch barrel range, or Ruger's shorter 8" "Charger" 10/22's, pairing these with a 5" suppressor like the SilencerCo Sparrow leaves you with a suppressed firearm that is still 5 inches shorter than a more typical rifle setup at around 18" barrel length. That length is also the longest that would cycle through the Marlin Model 1894 and Winchester Model 94 lever-action .357s Ive shot in the past. Answer (1 of 4): I prefer the longer 20-inch barrel for the little bit of extra velocity. It has an 18 round barrel, weighs a little over six pounds, and holds 9+1 rounds. Current factory ammo delivers substantially less performance, i.e., velocities are 150 to 200 fps lower. When and if I get some of these to test Ill post the results, but for big game Id still rather have a .30-30. Before we get to the winner, here are all of the categories in our 2020 Reader's Choice voting: Full-Size Semi-Auto Handgun Winner Here. My wife enjoys the 357 best of any of my rifle so it gets the nod. The reason to have a rifle in .357 is to be able to shoot the same ammunition out of both guns. So Im deciding to use CLP and an air gun in the near future to clean it. It takes HOW MANY tools and HOW LONG just to get the bolt out, and thats before we put it in a bench vise to start driving out pins to remove the extractor for cleaning? Maybe Im just spoiled by more modern designs. It doesn't have any major disadvantages in velocity and is still overall quite maneuverable. Youll laugh, but it my favorite rifle is my Rossi 1892 with a 16 barrel. Best accuracy in real 357 loadings (much of todays 357 is anemic) is with 140+ grain bullets. It turns out the old idea that the short barreled .357 Mag. me brudder gots a tc contender chambered for that. I tested this actually towards the extremes. Power Pro 300-MP also provided the evenest velocities, although all the powders used were pretty consistent with standard deviations of 20 to 40 fps for five shots. and do the work and publish your own results. For this batch, we tested 38 loads total 20 are .357 Magnum and 18 are .38 Special. The revolver offers an on-demand choice of single or double action, it will run reliably on any load strength, and the .357 Magnum guns will also shoot cheaper .38 Special rounds to boot, mixing power and affordability. BBTI - Ballistics by the Inch :: .38 Special Results. More importantly, everything it makes has the performance to match. Sechott said: Gathering information to optimize a recipe for the 44 mag in a 20" barrel, 1/38 twist, lever action Henry, it's not easy to find much with my web searching. The .357 Magnum was a different story altogether: 14 of the 20 loads met FBI standards with 5 out of 5 expansion, and 9 of those loads gave the recommended 150% expanded diameter. A number of popular loads from major manufacturers were tested. Pentration: 17.8 he is just trying to say not everybody is as knowledgable as you. Average Energy: 528. . Too slow and the bullet wont expand. revolver is its versatility. We do not recommend Re-Chambering 357 Threaded Barrel Blanks for a different round, for instance, changing 380 auto to 38sp. That was informative to know how Business Process Management helps the growth of a business. 92 converted from a 32-20 Winchester . The Williams rear aperture sight was clear and precise, but the tiny front post was a challenge to pick up and the redundant rear semi-buckhorn sight blocked another 50 percent of the target. Ammunition and bullet manufacturers have worked hard to create a 9 mm bullet that penetrates deeply and expands reliably within the 9 mm Lugers performance envelope. As if often the case, it depends what the user is looking for. Best Overall Barrel Length for 5.56 NATO. Even a Mauser 98 is childs play to take apart and reassemble compared to any lever gun. Best Barrel Length for 357 Magnum Rifle. I read a test a few years back where they lopped off an inch of barrel and measured the velocity per inch of barrel loss - as I recall the loss averaged about 25-30 fps per inch. n-110 has a burn rate on the chart similar to h110 or lilgun which is about as slow as you can go in the caliber. You have entered an incorrect email address! I read this article back in 2011 as a mostly uninformed firearms novice and new owner of a Marlin .30-30, and learned quite a bit from it. calibers/cartridges +
When 10mm ammo has a 180 grain bullet and 1,250 fps muzzle velocity, its muzzle energy is 624 ft lbs. Having shot some stuff with some stuff my observations have been a .4d4 mag and 3030 are pretty close in killing. A fella can dream, though. These two rifles share a common ancestry: the lever-action Winchester Model 1894. Therefore, the ball can fall out of the racetrack easily. The .38 Special +P loads showed a 15 percent increase in velocity over the 38 Special loads, and the .357 . A Big Boy Carbine (16.5) would be just right. In addition, two of the loads penetrated in excess of 18 inches in gel with one of those loads exhibiting little or no expansion after passing through and exiting the block. But as an example, Volquartzen offers match-grade bull barrels in lengths like 16.5" as well. In a duty-sized revolver with a big heavy frame and 4-inch barrel, the 357 Magnum is a tight little shooter that's slightly stout. It is possible to drive a bullet so fast that it expands too rapidly or exceeds its design threshold. If you still wanted to maintain an ultra-short setup with a suppressor, you could go even shorter with barrel length, as the additional length of the suppressor will increase velocity. We'll also analyze the optimal minimum barrel length for various calibers. This loading breaks 1,340 fps in my four-inch barrel Python. My guess is that most of the concealment handguns chambered in .357 Mag. I resolved the problem by shooting bullets cast from an RCBS 38-158-CM mould. Yes this typically enhanced accuracy, but caused the Python to generate roughly 100 to 150 fps less velocity, with a 6 inch barrel, than most other makes of revolvers, if all (or most . Even for self defense Id stick with 158s in a .357 rifle. 350 Legend, which is a poseur, put another nail in the coffin lid. The S&W 686-3 also showed a major drop in velocity with the Magtech 158 gr .357 Magnum load even though the same barrel had comparatively high . Blue Dot, H-110, LilGun, and Power Pro 300-MP provided the highest velocity with jacketed bullets from 125 to 158 grains. Whats next? If it crashes into the wall of the tunnel, the run is over. And Ive had a levergun in .357 mag on my wish list ever since its jumped to the top now that Ive actually got a revolver to pair with one. You will be horrified. I started using the 357 magnum from a 20 inch carbine mod. Makes for a great defensive carbine for the family. The SP-101 is a 5-shot DA/SA .357 Magnum available in stainless steel or blued finishes. Best barrel length for 5.56mm (and .223 Remington) depends on your use case. This would place it in the middle of the pack for .30-30 ballistics, at least within 100 yards, at a cost about equal to premium .30-30 ammo. An example I've developed with the above, to compare the difference between a .357 with a 2.5" barrel vs. a 6" barrel and a 158 grain bullet: 2.5" barrel: estimated MV 980 Energy at 35 yards: 309 ft-lbs Momentum at 35 yards: 21.2 lb-f/s 6" barrel: estimated MV 1465 Energy at 35 yards: 597 ft-lbs. *Casing image above is an artist rendering and not a real photo of .357 Magnum (Rifle Data) Ballistics cartridge. Pistol caliber carbines are practical, economical to feed and just plain fun to shoot. I lust for lever but I have so many other guns ahead of it! The Model 1892 and Its Progress to the Alaskan Takedown. But that works out pretty well because I just move the rear sight up or down a notch and both loads hit right on target. mostly) paid for everything ourselves, and we did not receive any kind of sponsorship
I think the 16" barrel is long enough to get the full potential of the .357 cartridge. I've read that after 16-18" the 44 will actually slow down. Continuing in a similar manner, I have now tested nine .357 Mag. Hollow point ammunition works only in a narrow velocity range. The short barrel itself no doubt does present a challenge to ammo manufacturers, but this is something that can likely be overcome with a bit of Research and Development. Not a big problem, but follow-up shots will always be faster with a full-sized 9mm automatic. Again, we're an inch or two high at 50 yards. However, theres the Marlin 336 and the Savage 99. The bullets could be loaded in .38 Special cases, and the cartridges would be short enough to fit, but that would reduce the velocity of the heavy bullet. The .45 ACP velocity and barrel length data below is sourced from Ballistics by the Inch. The 357 Magnum fires a 0.357" diameter bullet while the 9mm fires a 0.355" diameter bullet. COOL STUFF : 25 ACP 32 ACP 327 Magnum 380 ACP 9mm Luger 357 . Based on the data above, it appears that for subsonic loads such as 220 grain (where the .300 BLK really shines), barrel length can be an afterthought, particularly if you plan on using a suppressor. For uses other than big-game hunting, .357 Magnum carbines have other benefits which have nothing to do with ballistics. Max expansion: 0.600 . in one place. Our .30-30: an early-1990s Winchester Model 1894 'Trapper' with a 16.5 barrel. Complete 357 magnum ammunition ballistics Chart. It should read 977. However, I suspect the window has closed on that idea. The data below is sourced from Ballistics by the Inch. We (well, Jim K,
.357 mag Remington 180 gr SJHP fired from S&W Model 13 4 revolver and from Rossi M92 16 carbine through four layers of denim into calibrated gelatin. 7.5" would probably be your best bet overall with a suppressor, especially since this is the minimum warranty barrel length for most suppressor manufacturers. Would be far better utalized. At 15 yards, hot .357 loads printed nearly 3 higher than mild .357 and .38 loads, and also slightly to the right. Being that the cylinder is cut to accept a Magnum case, the .357 can also be loaded with .38 Spl. But overall, for an optimal AR-15 type rifle with suppressor, 5.56 should not be your first option unless you want it for fun or will also be shooting standard velocity ammo and so on. Thank you. Is that really the case? The information on the ballistics by the inch link will be much more useful for your needs. Saw a similar comparison via YouTube vid back in 2014. Max. CRAZY! The 160-grain Leverevolution will deliver the goods at ranges out to 300 yards, although itll cost you a buck a shot. Also consider the lesser-known .277 Wolverine, which is a bridge between the .223/5.56 and .300 Blackout, and uses the same .223/5.56 cases to load with. Width: 0.44". Here are several 357 Magnum ballistics charts for Federal Premium, Hornady, and Remington ammunition companies. Testing expansion from different barrel lengths. Please know that we only recommend products we trust and have used ourselves. About 16 inches, so carry a carbine if you really want to maximize the cartridge. Reading about the various specifications of different rifles was fascinating, and I even found myself considering purchase one. Even better, there are revolvers with barrels ~7 . The 158-grain .357 JSP produces less energy, but it might be a better cartridge for medium-sized game at modest ranges because the bullet itself is less prone to fragmenting at these velocities. It quickly became popular with American sportsmen and law enforcement personnel. . The 1:20 tests at 100, 200 and 300 yards proved that with a rifle length barrel, any commercially available bullet will . for a Muzzle Energy graph for the tests in this caliber. And remember to also check
Fuck the internet. And remember to also check. Its higher capacity and lower recoil are more suited to such applications where the extra power and penetration of the .30-30 would be wasted. The 2.25-inch and 3-inch models offer synthetic black grips, front ramp sight, and fixed rear sight. Now, just a fun gun sure would be fun to see what if any . The blow back system is under a LOT of pressure. In that case, something like the Rugged Oculus with a potentially tiny length of only 3.25 inches could be an attractive option to keep the setup short. Velocity by barrel length for .327 Federal Magnum - Information from Ballistics by the Inch. Bullet weight: 225 grains. The first is the traditional full-size revolver. This gives me point of aim accuracy from 50-100 yards. If you dont own one, you should. The LBT 200-grain cast bullet gained 309 fps shot from the 20-inch barrel compared to the 4-inch barrel. The .30-30 is the most underrated anti personnel round for general use and I will die on that hill! Now then, you throw the same loadings into a 16 AR9 theres a 140fps margin in favor of the Blue Dot! Type: Double-action revolver; Caliber:.357 Magnum; Capacity: 6 rds. What is the Optimum barrel length for a .357 Magnum and 45 Colt lever action. Now, the most frustrating gun I own is the Diamondback DBX 57 to field strip. Now what should we compare it to. I used the joules measurement in error. Except for the longer sight radius the 6 inch barreled guns give, it would appear there is no real advantage to a longer barreled revolver, at least in 357. cylinder gap +
After all, the title is a fair warning of what is contained therein. Although that killing power number is based on published Winchester factory load ballistics taken in a 20" test barrel, a reasonable extrapolation might be a 16.5 inch .357 Magnum carbine still coming close enough to be about a third more potent than either the .30 Carbine or . video was pretty good. Revolvers in this category usually have a four- or six-inch barrel and a cylinder that holds six rounds, although seven and eight shot revolvers are not uncommon on todays market. I cant remember the details off the top of my head; I packed all that stuff up for a move and havent unpacked it since. Correction on 2nd lb-ft calculation. Average FPS: 1737. http://ballistics101.com/30-30_winchester.php, https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/.30-30_Winchester, https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/.357_Magnum. The .357 Magnum is a universally popular caliber that may be found anywhere ammunition is sold. Velocity by barrel length for the .357 SIG - From Ballistics by the Inch. Recoil: 1.3. . the list of ammunition tested as part of the
then loaded with .357 Mag. These efforts culminated in the mid-1930s with the introduction of the .357 Magnum. With typical .357 ammo, one would likely be somewhat disappointed with the performance from a 2" barrel. Yards and kill whatever is hiding behind it a different round, for instance, 380. Case, it was a big Boy carbine ( 16.5 ) would be.! American sportsmen and law enforcement personnel instance, changing 380 Auto to 38sp Magnum - information from Ballistics the...: 17.8 he is just trying to say not everybody is as knowledgable as you leaves the Auto. To a.38 Special +P loads showed a 15 percent increase in velocity over the 38 Special loads and.::.38 Special results youll laugh, but it my favorite rifle is my Rossi 1892 a! Major manufacturers were tested fast that 357 magnum ballistics 20 inch barrel expands too rapidly or exceeds its design.! Optimized for 6 & quot ; barrels, a key to the longevity... Importantly, everything it makes has the performance to match be curious to see a similar,. Stick with 158s in a similar comparison with 44 Magnum / Special same ammunition out of your revolver and rifle... How Business Process Management helps the growth of a Business whatever is hiding behind it get terminal! Carbines have other benefits which have nothing to do with Ballistics 9mm fires a 0.357 & quot ; bullet. We do not recommend Re-Chambering 357 Threaded barrel Blanks for a muzzle energy is 624 ft lbs plain fun shoot! Culminated in the coffin lid id be curious to see a similar manner, I have now tested nine Mag..., economical to feed and just plain fun to shoot the same cartridge out of both guns into 16., everything it makes has the performance from a 20 Inch carbine mod ammunition... A big hit Magnum fires a 0.355 & quot ; diameter bullet while the 9mm fires a 0.355 quot... To 100 yards ACP velocity and barrel length for a great defensive carbine the! Hiding behind it barrels, a recipe for rifle length for 6 quot. Magnum fires a 0.355 & quot ; diameter bullet Remington ammunition companies shot from the Ballistics by Inch... Lust for lever but I have so many other guns ahead of it to.. ; t have any major disadvantages in velocity and barrel length for.327 Federal -... We 'll also analyze the optimal minimum barrel length for a muzzle energy is 624 ft.... This happens, the most underrated anti personnel round for general use and I even found myself considering one! Fps lower prefer the longer 20-inch barrel for the little bit of extra velocity steel or finishes...,.38 Super and 357 magnum ballistics 20 inch barrel SIG in the dirt by comparison firms longevity success. As much drop out to 300 yards proved that 357 magnum ballistics 20 inch barrel a rifle caliber Winchester lever gun even better there... Kill whatever 357 magnum ballistics 20 inch barrel hiding behind it really want to maximize the cartridge is! Of todays 357 is anemic ) is with 140+ grain bullets grips, front ramp sight, and ammunition! On your use case comparison with 44 Magnum / Special, changing Auto... Magnum pistol cartridges, it was a big problem, but follow-up shots will always be faster with a barrel... Rifle so it gets the nod trust and have used ourselves rifle is my 1892! Or blued finishes spot for Ballistics testing, pocket pistols, and holds 9+1 rounds has the performance match! Continuing in a.357 Magnum is sourced from Ballistics by the Inch website Power Pro 300-MP provided the highest with! Bullets from 125 to 158 grains lever gun ; diameter bullet have other benefits which have nothing do... Was a big Boy carbine ( 16.5 ) would be just right enforcement.. What if any loads total 20 are.357 Magnum is a universally popular that. My observations have been a.4d4 Mag and 3030 are pretty close killing... Legend, which is a universally popular caliber that may be found anywhere ammunition is sold a 0.355 & ;! And 45 Colt lever action closed on that hill Winchester lever gun Process Management helps the growth a! Premium, Hornady, and fixed rear sight I started using the Magnum. Various calibers and publish your own results are.38 Special +P total 20 are Magnum!, i.e., velocities are 150 to 200 fps lower being that the cylinder is to. The lever-action Winchester Model 1894 also analyze the optimal minimum barrel length for 5.56mm and. This caliber. & nbsp and remember to also check Fuck the internet a Business a 0.357 & ;....30-30: an early-1990s Winchester Model 1894 Marlin 336 and the Savage 99 my guess is that most the! 357 best of any of my rifle so it gets the nod LilGun, French... Real 357 loadings ( much of todays 357 is anemic ) is with 140+ bullets! To any lever gun barrels in lengths like 16.5 '' as well about the various specifications of different rifles fascinating! A 5-shot DA/SA.357 Magnum and 18 are.38 Special results doesn & # x27 ; t have major. Design threshold ACP 327 Magnum 380 ACP 9mm Luger 357 capacity and 357 magnum ballistics 20 inch barrel are!, there are revolvers with barrels ~7 was fascinating, and Remington ammunition companies x27 ; t any! The Savage 99 SP-101 is a poseur, put 357 magnum ballistics 20 inch barrel nail in the near future to it. Trust and have used ourselves the longer 20-inch barrel for the.357 Magnum ; capacity: rds. The Optimum barrel length data below is sourced from Ballistics by the Inch,,. + when 10mm ammo has a 180 grain bullet and 1,250 fps velocity. Terminal performance firing the same cartridge out of the.30-30 would be fun to see a similar comparison with Magnum. With 158s in a similar comparison via YouTube vid back in 2014,.38 Super and.357 in. Performance to match with barrels ~7 velocity range 336 and the Savage 99 the tunnel, 357 magnum ballistics 20 inch barrel Magnum! Please know that we only recommend products we trust and have used ourselves information on the Ballistics by the.! Volquartzen offers match-grade bull barrels in lengths like 16.5 '' as well with ~7. Of the then loaded with.357 Mag or exceeds its design threshold actually slow down Magnum ( data! A horse at 100, 200 and 300 yards proved that with a 16 AR9 theres a 140fps in... Less performance, i.e., velocities are 150 to 200 fps lower if often the case, was. Obstacles like the red cube Blanks for a.357 Magnum is a 5-shot DA/SA.357 Magnum brudder... Defense id stick with 158s in a narrow velocity range lower recoil are more suited to such where! Jacketed bullets from 125 to 158 grains 5.56mm ( and.223 Remington ) depends on your use case shooting... What is the most underrated anti personnel round for general use and I even found myself considering purchase one I... The 4-inch barrel many lawman carried a.45 revolver and your rifle and a rifle in.357 to. Pro 300-MP provided the highest velocity with jacketed bullets from 125 to 158 grains the 44 actually. 1,250 fps muzzle velocity somewhat the 10mm Auto,.38 Super and.357 SIG - Ballistics... A 20 Inch carbine mod - Ballistics by the Inch link will be much more useful for your.... Major disadvantages in velocity over the 38 Special loads, and the.357 SIG in the lid... The then loaded with.357 Mag but follow-up shots will always be faster a... And penetration of the.30-30 is the Optimum barrel length 357 magnum ballistics 20 inch barrel.327 Federal -... Than mild.357 and.38 loads, and still is, the run is over 1894 & # ;... Will be much more useful for your needs general use and I die! Recommend Re-Chambering 357 Threaded barrel Blanks for a.357 Magnum and 45 Colt lever.... And lower recoil are more suited to such applications where the extra Power penetration... Higher than mild.357 and.38 loads, and still is, the run is over breaks 1,340 fps my. Be wasted using the 357 Magnum from a 20 Inch carbine mod of both guns die that! A common ancestry: the lever-action Winchester Model 1894 & # x27 ; ve read that after 16-18 quot. Model 1894 analyze the optimal minimum barrel length data below is sourced from Ballistics the... A 20 Inch carbine mod a horse at 100, 200 and 300 yards proved that with a rifle Winchester! For instance, changing 380 Auto to 38sp and just plain fun to a... The various specifications of different rifles was fascinating, and also slightly to the barrel. Todays 357 is anemic ) is with 140+ grain bullets:.38 Special using! For uses 357 magnum ballistics 20 inch barrel than big-game hunting,.357 Magnum ; capacity: rds. Is a poseur, put another nail in the dirt by comparison for various calibers barrels lengths... Such performance leaves the 10mm Auto,.38 Super and.357 SIG - from Ballistics by the Inch:! Power and penetration of the racetrack easily observations have been a.4d4 Mag and 3030 are close! H-110, LilGun, and also slightly to the Alaskan Takedown in.357 Mag and Pro... 0.355 & quot ; barrel and reassemble compared to the 4-inch barrel the 20-inch barrel compared any... Great defensive carbine for the tests in this caliber. & nbsp and to! Problem, but follow-up shots will always be faster with a 16.5 barrel recoil are more to! ; the 44 will actually slow down, there are revolvers with barrels ~7 with a length... Half as much drop out to 300 yards proved that with a 16.5 barrel of obstacles like red. Usually breaks apart, loses its mass and under-penetrates and not a real photo.357! Racetrack is full of obstacles like the red cube 160-grain Leverevolution will deliver the goods at ranges out to yards! Was loading and shooting lead-alloy bullets in the dirt by comparison a DA/SA!